| Passing Yards in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 3744 | Austin | Berry | 2002-2005 | |
| Passing Yards in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 2017 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | |
| Passing Yards in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 304 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | Hancock County |
| Passing TDs in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 47 | Austin | Berry | 2002-2005 | |
| Passing TDs in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 29 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | |
| Passing TDs in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 4 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | Fulton City |
| 4 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | McLean County |
| 4 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | Webster County |
| 4 | Taylon | Polk | 2006 | Logan County |
| Passing Completions in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 227 | Austin | Berry | 2002-2005 | |
| Passing Completions in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 122 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | |
| Passing Completions in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 24 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | Hancock County |
| Passing Attempts in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 426 | Jamie | Curtis | 1989-1992 | |
| Passing Attempts in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 203 | Jamie | Curtis | 1991 | |
| 203 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | |
| Passing Attempts in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 36 | Austin | Berry | 2004 | Hancock County |
| Interceptions Thrown in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 50 | Jamie | Curtis | 1989-1992 | |
| Interceptions Thrown in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 22 | Jamie | Curtis | 1991 | |
| Interceptions Thrown in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 6 | Jamie | Curtis | 1992 | Russellville |
| Rushing Yards in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 3911 | David | Beverly | 1994-1997 | |
| Rushing Yards in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 1581 | Jimmy | Hopper | 1963 | |
| Rushing Yards in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 343 | Jimmy | Hopper | 1963 | Sturgis |
| Rushing TDs Scored in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 38 | Dennis | Mott | 1961-1964 | |
| Rushing TDs Scored in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 22 | Jimmy | Hopper | 1963 | |
| Rushing TDs Scored in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 5 | Jimmy | Hopper | 1963 | Sturgis |
| 5 | Jeff | Matz | 1980 | Greenville |
| 5 | Ronnie | Moss | 1988 | Reidland |
| 5 | Jeramie | Sorina | 2006 | Caverna |
| Rushing Attempts in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 608 | David | Beverly | 1994-1997 | |
| Rushing Attempts in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 261 | David | Beverly | 1996 | |
| Rushing Attempts in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 41 | Jeramie | Sorina | 2006 | Russellville |
| Receiving Yards in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 1774 | T.K. | Guess | 2002-2005 | |
| Receiving Yards in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 900 | T.K. | Guess | 2004 | |
| Receiving Yards in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 174 | Kyle | Myers | 1997 | McLean County |
| Receiving TDs in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 17 | T.K. | Guess | 2002-2005 | |
| Receiving TDs in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 12 | T.K. | Guess | 2004 | |
| Receiving TDs in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 3 | Jamie | Champion | 1963 | Christian County |
| 3 | Jamie | Champion | 1963 | Henderson Douglas |
| 3 | Mike | Tosh | 1972 | Fulton County |
| 3 | Cody | Robinson | 2003 | Muhlenberg North |
| 3 | Rodney | Robertson | 2006 | Logan County |
| Receptions in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 95 | T.K. | Guess | 2002-2005 | |
| Receptions in a Season | Name | Season | ||
| 45 | T.K. | Guess | 2004 | |
| Receptions in a Game | Name | Season | Opponent | |
| 10 | T.K. | Guess | 2004 | Mayfield |
| TDs Scored in a Career | Name | Seasons | ||
| 46 | T.K. | Guess | 2002-2005 | |